So that's the proof that Muhammad didn't write the Qur'an.
But since you don't yet believe it, let's have this analyzed.
1. Muhammad was illiterate.
He cannot read nor write, therefore no one can accuse him of being the writer of Qur'an.
If you do so, it's like accusing your father gave birth to a child. Impossible.
2. Muhammad never claimed so.
He never claimed that Qur'an is his words. He said those are Allah's words.
So you can't accuse something that a person claims never did.
If you do so, it's like accusing Barrack Obama as a muslim, despite his clear denial.
3. Muhammad recited the Qur'an for 22 years.
Whenever new verses are revealed, he immediately memorized them and instructed the companions either to memorize or write down. Since he recited it, there is no 'editorial process', which means whatever being said cannot be taken back. Imagine the level of consistency that he had to maintain. With over 600+ pages of verses over such long period, any mistake will be pointed out immediately by non-believers who are always denying him.
4. He didn't get any help.
Since he was the first Muslim, then nobody was there to help him. No-one was around him for the whole 22 years to assist him. Qur'an is in perfect Arabic language, so whoever taught him must be of Arabic mother-tongue with excellent knowledge in everything. So no proof of him getting outside help. Furthermore, nobody raised hand and claim the verse are theirs.
5. No, he didn't copy from Bible nor Torah.
Bible in arabic is non-existent at that time. In fact, he cannot read, no library, Internet or Y!A. In fact the content of Qur'an is obvious opposite with Bible, such as Jesus as God. Many scientific mistakes in the Bible were not copied over, such as World's creation, Noah Ark, World is Flat etc. If he copied over, how did he know which one is wrong and not to copy?
6. The Qur'an says everything bad about satan, nothing good.
In fact, whenever someone reads and recite Qur'an, always start with ';I seek refuge with Allah from Satan, the accursed';. A verse in Qur'an:
“Verily, Satan is an enemy to you, so treat him as an enemy. He only invites his adherents, that they may become companions of the Blazing Fire.” (35: 6)
7. He denied money, power, women and slaves to stop teaching Qur'an %26amp; Islam.
In fact, there were several attempts to kill him. When he died, he only had a small house with almost nothing valuable inside, despite being the leader of the country. Clearly worldly benefits are not his objectives.
8. So who's words the Qur'an is?
I know there are kids who will curse here, so kids, please behave. I didn't curse your religion / god, whether it is Jesus Christ, YWYH, Buddha, YMCA, Money or Alcohol.So you want proof that Muhammad didn't write the Qur'an?
The day-to-day life of the Prophet was an open book for all to see. In fact a revelation came asking people to give the Prophet (pbuh) privacy in his own home. If the Prophet had been meeting people who told him what to say as a revelation from God, this would not have been hidden for very long.
The extremely prominent Quraish nobles who followed the Prophet and accepted Islam were wise and intelligent men who would have easily noticed anything suspicious about the way in which the Prophet brought the revelations to them - more so since the Prophetic mission lasted 23 years.
The enemies of the Prophet kept a close watch on him in order to find proof for their claim that he was a liar - they could not point out even a single instance when the Prophet may have had a secret rendezvous with particular Jews and Christians.
It is inconceivable that any human author of the Qur’an would have accepted a situation in which he received no credit whatsoever for originating the Qur’an.
Thus, historically and logically it cannot be established that there was a human source for the Qur’an.
Is it not true that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) has copied the Qur’an from the Bible?
http://www.ilovezakirnaik.com/misconcept…So you want proof that Muhammad didn't write the Qur'an?
They still point it out today..and still you wont listen.
Report Abuse
Do you have any evidence for any of these claims?
Do you know what evidence is?
Every muslim will clearly tell you:
A) Muhammad was illiterate and got other dudes to write the Quran.
B) That Gabriel did recite all of the Quran to Muhammad.
C) And finally that regardless how many people it has been through, its still somehow magically accurate.
Muslims don't argue that Muhammad didn't write the Quran.
thanks for sharing. i thought i had read the same articles as you did.
with love and grace to Allah
I know he didn't it was written long after he died
salam, brother.
any sensible person would believe in allah if he read this....
but these people are not....so wont even try to understand...
I'll just tell you this, if it's in ';perfect Arabic'; why are there several different interpretations? It seems that Arabs have some difficulty understanding these words.
And yes, it contains plenty of reworked stories from the bible and the Jewish Apocrypha. And some of those were fables, which the Koran dutifully copied.
um, evidence?
Excuse me please, Has anybody here said Prophet Mohommed himself wrote Koran ? There is some one here who says so and argues too that he did not. He is said to be an ignorant moron who could not write anything.
Lol! We are all aware Muhamamd was dead when the Quran was put together..so obviously he did not physically pen the Quran...that doesnt prove the Quran is not his words...then again what does it matter who penned the Quran? The Quran disagrees with the word of God.
No dear, I don't have that much interest in bronze age middle eastern goat or camel herders fairy tales.
OK, so what is it that you're trying to say?
1. Muhammad was illiterate.
2.He never claimed that Qur'an was his words.
3. Muhammad recited the Qur'an for 22 years.
OK, thus far. So, where's the dispute?
4. He didn't get any help.
You might want to do some research before you say this. He had scribes write it for him. Please Google ';Abdullah ibn Sa`d Ibn Abi Sarh'; who was one of Mohammad's scribes [meaning he had more, by the way] who attained a bit of fame which is going to affect the rest of your claims, now.
5. No, he didn't copy from Bible nor Torah.
There's a difference between copying and plagiarizing that you might want to look up.
6. The Qur'an says everything bad about Satan, nothing good.
So, what's the big deal? I even has a ridiculous story about Allah making Adam 90 feet tall and telling the Angels to bow before him and that Satan got banished for not bowing to him. Then, it says that Satan got Adam and Eve to eat the fruit, where Adam didn't recognize the guy he got banished?
You really shouldn't have gone there.
7. He denied money, power, women and slaves to stop teaching Qur'an %26amp; Islam.
Huh?
';....to stop teaching Qur'an %26amp; Islam.';?!?!
Are you sure you know what you are saying?
Anyways, the very first premise is itself wrong because the share of his booty was quite a lot and is detailed in the Sahih Bukhari, the Sahih Muslim, the Kitaab al Thimidhi and the Kitaab wal sijaasa.
So, what are you trying to say here?
OK, the hadiths also say that all the people there used to go to an open field to pee and crap, which just means that they didn't know how to build a toilet, but nothing much else.
8. So who's words the Qur'an is?
You might want to go back to your English Language classes, too, among other things.
Anyways, the Koran is made up of the concoctions of Mohammad, written for him by his scribes, of which he approved 7 versions, four of which were preferred - the Qalun, the Warsh, the Hafs and the al Dhuri; each with two different renditions [riyaatein] and was later edited by the Caliph Uthman after his death.
So, where is your Unique, Unedited and in one language Koran?
In your dreams.
Because the versions are for the dialects of Arabic, primarily. And the riyaatein are to account for the differences of individual idiom. so, out goes your claim of one language.
Caliph Uthman edited the Koran and burned all the other copies he could. So, out goes your claim of Unchanged and Unique.
So, what else is left?
Oh, by the way, I'm an Adult.
the facts are
A) Muhammad was illiterate and got other dudes to write the Quran.
B) That Gabriel did recite all of the Quran to Muhammad.
C) The quran contains all the lies ,hatred and fictional stories just like the bible..
http://www.thedeenshow.com/show.php?acti…
Yes, I know all of this but it is not proof of the existence of god. Clearly they are the words of Muhammad.
';He cannot read nor write, therefore no one can accuse him of being the writer of Qur'an.';
The Qur'an was an oral tradition for the first hundred years before it was written down. That does not prove Mohammad didn't come up with it off the top of his head, all it proves is that he didn't actually write it down on a piece of paper. Whoop-de-doo, you've proved diddly.
';So you can't accuse something that a person claims never did.';
So if a killer says he never killed anyone, you can't accuse him of doing so? Sorry, that argument makes no sense at all.
';Imagine the level of consistency that he had to maintain.';
Look up ';abrogation';. I dare you.
';Since he was the first Muslim, then nobody was there to help him.';
Sorry, but that argument doesn't even work on the most basic level. Unless you're claiming that he was all alone for the entire time, never talking to anyone else (which would be a lie), your argument simply falls apart.
';In fact, he cannot read, no library, Internet or Y!A.';
Once again, unless you're claiming that he was all alone (and we know he wasn't, and we also know he hung out with a lot of Jews at the beginning of his prophetic ';career';), your argument doesn't work.
';The Qur'an says everything bad about satan, nothing good.';
So? Where is this ';satan';? Who is this ';satan';?
What exactly are you trying to prove here?
';He denied money, power, women and slaves to stop teaching Qur'an %26amp; Islam.';
Of course, he got plenty of all of the above by ';teaching'; Islam, so he didn't really need it.
';So who's words the Qur'an is?';
That would be Mohammad's. At least, you have done nothing to demonstrate that that isn't the case.
Muhammad received the bits and pieces of the puzzle (several verses of the AlQuran), one at a time over 22 years and put these verses in the designated place as soon as he received it (and never to juggle/sifted or move around) to form the final Quran as we find today.Subhanallah.
In short,he did wonders no man had done. No wonder his followers are growing inspite of the cruelty, lies and slanders the Muslims are facing.
No comments:
Post a Comment